brief(worldchest): decision brief for "BlockVault / WorldChest — backup, sync, restore & versioning for Minecraft Bedrock worlds" (discussion #5)

Merged
DO
1mo ago
+889-0

Decision brief — BlockVault — automatic backup, sync, restore & versioning for Minecraft worlds

Drafted by Mary (Analyst) via the org decision-brief stage for https://github.com/combsmith/incubator/discussions/5.
This brief informs the go/no-go; it does not make it. Approve the idea by adding
idea:approved to the source Discussion, or decline it there — not by merging this PR
(merging records the package; the incubation gate may stay red until the rest of the
package — brainstorm, PRD — exists).

Files

  • ideas/block-vault/brief.md
  • ideas/block-vault/market-research.md
  • ideas/block-vault/ost.md

Mary's status

Recommendation: park
Score: ICE 4×2×2=16
Status: partial

Assumptions tagged in the brief:

  • Parents will pay a recurring ~$5/mo Family plan (author hypothesis, no WTP evidence)
  • Outcome metric 'paying families with zero lost worlds across a device change' inferred; thread names none
  • Mojang will not ship native mobile cloud saves within ~18 months
  • The .mcworld share-sheet export works on current Bedrock mobile (Android 15, iOS)

Open questions for the decider:

  • Slug mismatch: thread set brand WorldChest and slug 'worldchest' on 2026-10-19; package generated as 'block-vault'
  • brainstorm.md missing (gate-required)
  • Does the Mojang EULA / Usage Guidelines permit a paid third-party backup service for user worlds?
  • COPPA / GDPR-K consent and data-minimisation architecture for under-13 users
  • Google Play policy for apps depending on Shizuku
  • iOS feasibility beyond manual .mcworld export
  • Current viability and install base of the com.draco.bedrock sync app
  • Frequency of world loss on device change and parent willingness to pay (market size unknown)

Sources cited: 13

Provenance

Every market claim in the package either cites a source, is tagged [ASSUMPTION], or says
"unknown — needs discovery" (enforced by scripts/decision-brief/validate-package.sh in
combsmith/.github-private before this PR was opened). Nothing here is fabricated to fill a section.

Run: https://github.com/combsmith/.github-private/actions/runs/39514037310

Problem

See the linked issue.

Risk

Low — documentation/configuration only; no runtime code paths change.

Test plan

No test files were added or updated. Verification: bash scripts/dev-lead-lint.sh (shellcheck --severity=warning) ran pre-commit; the existing CI (bats + lint) guards the change.

Rollback

Revert this PR. No non-revertible side effects (no tags, migrations, or external state).

Monitoring

n/a — no runtime effect; documentation/configuration only.